Skip to Main Content

Need help understanding your rights as an LGBTQ+ person or someone living with HIV? Visit our virtual Help Desk.

In re Spera

In re Spera

Status:

Closed

Outcome:

Victory

Court:

United States District Court for the Eastern District of Wisconsin

Issues:

Health Care Fairness, HIV

Attorneys:

Plaintiff

Stephen Spera

Attorneys

Co-counsel/Cooperating Attorneys
Peter M. Koneazny and Lisa Clay Foley of the Legal Aid Society of Milwaukee, Peter M. Kimball of the AIDS Resource Center of Wisconsin, and Amelia L. Bizzaro of Henak Law Office in Milwaukee, Wisconsin for the AIDS Resource Center of Wisconsin.

Case arguing that a doctor cannot refuse to perform surgery on a man because of his HIV status

Summary

Lambda Legal represented Stephen Spera, a Wisconsin man whose doctor refused to perform surgery on him because of his HIV status. Spera had sought treatment from an orthopedist for severe and debilitating back pain in 2000. For nearly two years, he received care from the orthopedist with a series of pain management procedures, but with little success. The doctor finally recommended spinal fusion surgery, and Spera submitted to a blood test to enter the hospital as a patient for surgery. The blood test revealed that Spera, who had previously tested negative for HIV, was HIV-positive. The orthopedist informed Spera of his status and said he would not perform the surgery. Lambda Legal sued, arguing that the doctor’s discriminatory actions were illegal under both federal and state law. The case has been successfully resolved.

Context

Both the federal Rehabilitation Act and Americans With Disabilities Act protect people with disabilities, including HIV, from discrimination by physicians. Wisconsin also has a law that prohibits health care providers from refusing to treat people, based only on their HIV status, if they would offer similar treatment to people who are HIV-negative.

Lambda Legal’s Impact

In this HIV discrimination case, Lambda Legal successfully argued that doctors are obliged by federal and Wisconsin state law to treat people with HIV. This is one of many Lambda Legal cases to ensure that people with HIV have fair and equal access to medical care and other key services.

History

  • October 2004 Lambda Legal files lawsuit arguing that a Wisconsin doctor illegally discriminated against his patient by refusing to perform surgery when he learned the man has HIV.
  • July 2006 The case is successfully resolved.